Respected Prime Minister
I as an Indian am proud to have a leader who is committed to work, A karamyogi working 24X7 selflessly for the country to make India a world leader. You are on mission of corruption free India, Digital India where Make in India products are admired all over the globe. Balancing the same with equal weightage to poor and farmers by introducing insurance, soil care and Jan Dhan accounts is not an easy job.
Your tough decisions like Surgical strikes, Demonetisation and GST rollout have been appreciated not in India but worldwide. I am one of your biggest admirers and have done my best to spread all your hard work and good results amongst masses.
However as a well wisher it is my duty to speak my heart out if I feel something has not gone well with a particular community and has created criticism about few words may be not taken well by them
This is regarding the CA Day on July 1 at IG Stadium. I had invitation from the institute and was very excited. However as I reached there at 3 PM and had to wait till 5,(gates did not open) amongst crowd getting restless and humidity on peak I decided to return. Sad state as the affair was organised by CA member also a member of BJP and he made it a political event rather than for professionals. I can vouch 80% of professionals returned without attending
Feeling disappointed I came back home. Excitedly I started to hear your speech thinking as if every word of yours is addressed to me as I am member of community and felt special. However for the first time after listening to your speech, I had mixed emotions.
The emotions got more confirmed when I saw pile of messages on Social Media with negativity. I understand that you did not try to say that all CA are corrupt but the message has been taken in that spirit.
Sir you said that " Doctors will never prescribe wrong things as they do not want patients to come back" However I can show you numerous examples where doctors have nexus with Pharma funds and Labs and they insist on surgery even if not required. SO CAN YOU SAY THAT ALL DOCTORS ARE CORRUPT?
You said that banks have huge NPA and CA who sign the balance sheets are responsible. I completely agree and I myself have tweeted 100 times that all NPA accounts CA should be scrutinised. However is it possible without fraudulent intent of bank officials who are supposed to take stock taking periodically which act as collateral security. CAN YOU TERM ALL BANK OFFICERS CORRUPT?
Everyone knows that goods from china are under invoiced and passed by corrupt officers who are bribed. The same has killed toy, shoes and handloom industry in our country. ARE CA RESPONSIBLE FOR THAT? CAN YOU CALL ALL CUSTOM OFFICERS CORRUPT?
People have lost their faith in judiciary which takes decades to decide an open and shut case like Laloo Prasad Yadav. Everyone knows how most politicians are corrupt . Unending scams of common wealth Games to 2G,3G,National Herald................CAN YOU SAY ALL POLITICIANS AND LAWYERS ARE CORRUPT?
You said that CA on Diwali holiday returned on 8th night as they had to help clients deal with black money. Is it necessary that all cash was black? What if a house wife calls me at 10 and cries that she had cash saved over years and does not know what to do? Should I not be available to help him?
I am writing all this as I am deeply hurt. Hurt not because you said against profession but majority of professionals who held high esteem of you have suddenly talking otherwise. Somewhere an Honest CA is hurt as he feels you painted all with one colour.
They were excited as it was a big Day for profession but they heard a little praise and more criticism from your side. May be the occasion did not match the words even if they were true
I am writing this as Lord Krishna said " A true well wisher is one who guides us to right direction not afraid of criticism that comes along" You might get upset but as far as I have experienced you embrace positivity
So when you said that " A CA signature is most important" why not add that your government will award such honest signatures every year and bring them to limelight. The positivity can be a game changer.
I am concerned about 2019 elections and like me millions want you to be PM again. So I am worried. I hate when I get unwarranted messages from CA community and do not have much to defend.
Hence as you Bhakt and an Honest CA I request you to take care of such wrong sentiments. How? You do not need any advice YOU ARE THE BEST.
I apologise if I sound rude or any of my words were not best suited. But honestly I had courage to right this as Mr Narendra Modi PM listens to every citizen and is large hearted to take criticism.
Warm Regards
Renuka Jain
I as an Indian am proud to have a leader who is committed to work, A karamyogi working 24X7 selflessly for the country to make India a world leader. You are on mission of corruption free India, Digital India where Make in India products are admired all over the globe. Balancing the same with equal weightage to poor and farmers by introducing insurance, soil care and Jan Dhan accounts is not an easy job.
Your tough decisions like Surgical strikes, Demonetisation and GST rollout have been appreciated not in India but worldwide. I am one of your biggest admirers and have done my best to spread all your hard work and good results amongst masses.
However as a well wisher it is my duty to speak my heart out if I feel something has not gone well with a particular community and has created criticism about few words may be not taken well by them
This is regarding the CA Day on July 1 at IG Stadium. I had invitation from the institute and was very excited. However as I reached there at 3 PM and had to wait till 5,(gates did not open) amongst crowd getting restless and humidity on peak I decided to return. Sad state as the affair was organised by CA member also a member of BJP and he made it a political event rather than for professionals. I can vouch 80% of professionals returned without attending
Feeling disappointed I came back home. Excitedly I started to hear your speech thinking as if every word of yours is addressed to me as I am member of community and felt special. However for the first time after listening to your speech, I had mixed emotions.
The emotions got more confirmed when I saw pile of messages on Social Media with negativity. I understand that you did not try to say that all CA are corrupt but the message has been taken in that spirit.
Sir you said that " Doctors will never prescribe wrong things as they do not want patients to come back" However I can show you numerous examples where doctors have nexus with Pharma funds and Labs and they insist on surgery even if not required. SO CAN YOU SAY THAT ALL DOCTORS ARE CORRUPT?
You said that banks have huge NPA and CA who sign the balance sheets are responsible. I completely agree and I myself have tweeted 100 times that all NPA accounts CA should be scrutinised. However is it possible without fraudulent intent of bank officials who are supposed to take stock taking periodically which act as collateral security. CAN YOU TERM ALL BANK OFFICERS CORRUPT?
Everyone knows that goods from china are under invoiced and passed by corrupt officers who are bribed. The same has killed toy, shoes and handloom industry in our country. ARE CA RESPONSIBLE FOR THAT? CAN YOU CALL ALL CUSTOM OFFICERS CORRUPT?
People have lost their faith in judiciary which takes decades to decide an open and shut case like Laloo Prasad Yadav. Everyone knows how most politicians are corrupt . Unending scams of common wealth Games to 2G,3G,National Herald................CAN YOU SAY ALL POLITICIANS AND LAWYERS ARE CORRUPT?
You said that CA on Diwali holiday returned on 8th night as they had to help clients deal with black money. Is it necessary that all cash was black? What if a house wife calls me at 10 and cries that she had cash saved over years and does not know what to do? Should I not be available to help him?
I am writing all this as I am deeply hurt. Hurt not because you said against profession but majority of professionals who held high esteem of you have suddenly talking otherwise. Somewhere an Honest CA is hurt as he feels you painted all with one colour.
They were excited as it was a big Day for profession but they heard a little praise and more criticism from your side. May be the occasion did not match the words even if they were true
I am writing this as Lord Krishna said " A true well wisher is one who guides us to right direction not afraid of criticism that comes along" You might get upset but as far as I have experienced you embrace positivity
So when you said that " A CA signature is most important" why not add that your government will award such honest signatures every year and bring them to limelight. The positivity can be a game changer.
I am concerned about 2019 elections and like me millions want you to be PM again. So I am worried. I hate when I get unwarranted messages from CA community and do not have much to defend.
Hence as you Bhakt and an Honest CA I request you to take care of such wrong sentiments. How? You do not need any advice YOU ARE THE BEST.
I apologise if I sound rude or any of my words were not best suited. But honestly I had courage to right this as Mr Narendra Modi PM listens to every citizen and is large hearted to take criticism.
Warm Regards
Renuka Jain
Understandably as honest CA you might have been hurt by PM'S remarks. But PM had very aptly placed the facts of CA'S being involved in "adjusting" black monies not only for business but even for politicians as well. Certification by CA for NPA's is not at all any issue and CA's are covered by the disclaimer they mention in the Annual ReportS. CA's have been the generator of bogus companies for "setting" the black monies for their clients for quite a long time now.
ReplyDeleteFormation of a company is not only a CA's issue, get your facts straight first of all. Secondly, if u r a businessman working with all your concise, following all the laws, but in your field only u will find some violating them, so should I name your entire community as a bad one????
DeleteGenerator of black money, liable for conviction. And it's a humble request, understand things before forming an opinion. I can list out no. Of Chartered Accountants working for the best of this country, so what are your views on that??
Think twice before u speak or express ur views in any form.
Well done Renukaji expressing the feelings of scores of st.forward CAs hurt by the speech
ReplyDeleteNice representation
ReplyDeleteCorruption is to entrenched and intertwined that we got used to it. We expect a babu to ask for money. No one ever thought, at least me that I could witness efforts to be in a corruption free society. But the rut of 60 years cant go away in just 5. We need 15 yrs. The replacement of Old guard appears to be the only solution coupled with such pushing from govt. If he spoke all good about CAs some would still have been hurt as both good and bad still would have got equated. So it might have been a catch 22 for him.
ReplyDeleteCorruption is to entrenched and intertwined that we got used to it. We expect a babu to ask for money. No one ever thought, at least me that I could witness efforts to be in a corruption free society. But the rut of 60 years cant go away in just 5. We need 15 yrs. The replacement of Old guard appears to be the only solution coupled with such pushing from govt. If he spoke all good about CAs some would still have been hurt as both good and bad still would have got equated. So it might have been a catch 22 for him.
ReplyDeleteAs myself CA, was equally hurt. Not all CAs are corrupt and I believe they work very sincerely and according to rules framed by politicians, hence CAs can't be held responsible for whay is the fault of law makers and who is the law maker? You Mr. Modi,hence blaMing others is not correct. Modi has publicly denegraded profession by loosely talking like this. If anyone don't follow the rule he may be punished according to law, that all.
ReplyDeleteAs most politicians are corrupt modiji is boss of many such politicians.. But he is unable to control them.. Then what is the use.. There are only one possibility is there that is he is also involved with them that is the only reason he is silent on political corruption..
ReplyDeleteAs most politicians are corrupt modiji is boss of many such politicians.. But he is unable to control them.. Then what is the use.. There are only one possibility is there that is he is also involved with them that is the only reason he is silent on political corruption..
ReplyDeleteI support your views....I feel same so
ReplyDeleteModi is not worth for praise. He never understood the ca profession and professional talent power which would have been used for nation building. 45 lakhs crore npa is not contributed by ca. It is once again government projects which require loans. The same loan creates black money but in modi's case he has not traced any black money. Now one has to suspect intention of prime minister.
ReplyDelete